Recently Nature Methods published an article on an open source information management system for biological laboratories, called OpenFreezer [1]. OpenFreezer is a fantastic effort and is a freely available software package that is currently used by several laboratories at the Samuel Lunenfeld Research Institute at the Mount Sinai Hospital in Canada.
OpenFreezer recognizes that there is a strong and growing need for flexible tracking system for managing biological resources and addresses this need with their software package that can be downloaded from http://openfreezer.org/
At Quartzy, we believe in the need for such software to manage reagent information given the growth of such collections and we are pleased to have researchers from other parts of the world addresses this unmet need. Given the similarity of our respective missions, it is important to outline how Quartzy differs from OpenFreezer.
The main difference is that OpenFreezer can be installed on a server at your institution while the Quartzy site is hosted by us on our servers. From this difference arise a few notable points of distinction:
Installation: Your IT staff needs to install and customize the OpenFreezer code on your server. With Quartzy you and your lab can create an account at any time and you are ready to start using the site right away.
Trust: If you use Quartzy then you trust us with your data. If you use software like OpenFreezer then your data is on your server and either controlled by you or your IT staff.
Updates: If you are a long-time Quartzy member then you know that we are constantly iterating and improving the Quartzy code-base. Two years ago we launched with just the inventory management module, and since then we launched three additional modules that help you manage your facilities, orders, and protocols. Over the last two years we have built relationships with leading vendors in the space like Sigma-Aldrich, Life Technologies and others and we host their catalogs so that you can add products to your inventories with ease. Soon we will be launching smart-phone apps. We push new code to the site twice a month. Such rapid and continuous deployment is possible when we host the code on our servers. With OpenFreezer the development cycle could potentially be longer since it is unlikely that your IT staff will update the code-base twice a month.
Back-up: If you were to use Quartzy then you have the benefit of knowing that your data is being backed up by us. I guess this again falls in the category of trust; you trust us when we say that we take extreme care to back-up your inventories. Every day the Quartzy database is backed to a separate drive and every two weeks it is moved to tape and moved off-site. And on Quartzy, you can send yourself Excel backups as frequently as every week. When you host your database on your server back-ups become your or your IT staff’s responsibility.
Free: A lot of researchers are still smarting from the time when VectorNTI ramped up it’s prices after it was bought by Invitrogen. We often get asked about this issue, and while it is one of our founding principles (hence the tagline: “Quartzy is and will always be free”), and is incorporated into our business model, you need to trust us to believe that. With OpenFreezer you can be sure that you will always have free access to the software that you have downloaded and installed.
Modifications: Another advantage to using OpenFreezer is that you and your IT staff are free to customize the software to meet your need. With Quartzy the way it works is that you would send us a suggestion/feature request and based on how many people were requesting the same feature it would get into the product pipeline and would be prioritized. So with Quartzy members often make suggestions and influence the product there is no guarantee that your specific suggestion would get done, while with OpenFreezer you are free to rework the code and add modules to develop it as per your needs.
Support: If you use Quartzy then you already know that we are just an email away. We respond to questions from our members all over the world, often in just a couple of hours. If you use OpenFreezer then you have to depend on your IT staff or the source documentation.
Fundamentally, the difference also is that Quartzy is a for-profit company while OpenFreezer is not-for-profit. The Quartzy website is free for scientists to use but we are focused on building a viable company around our core product so that we can continue developing the product, offering support, and building a community of scientists. At the same time, there is a long and illustrious history of open source software from the Linux OS to the plasmid software that we recently reviewed, which has made fundamental contributions to society.
Those are the differences as we see them and in the end your choice will be dictated by your needs. We would love to hear your thoughts and comments below.
[1] OpenFreezer: a reagent information management software system, Olhovsky, M. et. al., Nature Methods 8, 612–613 (2011) (http://www.nature.com/nmeth/journal/v8/n8/full/nmeth.1658.html)